101Leafy researched the games.

Home › Super Mario 64 › Enemies › Unagi

Unagi

ウツボ

English
Unagi
Japanese
ウツボ
Courses
Jolly Roger Bay

From the Player's Guide

The giant eel, Unagi, lives in Jolly Roger Bay. You can play with it and take the star from its tail, but you can't defeat it.

Super Mario 64 Player's Guide (Nintendo of America, 1996) p12

From the 百科

ウツボ: Has a long, big body. Lives in the sunken ship and a rock hole on the sea floor.

スーパーマリオブラザーズ百科 (Shogakukan, 2015) p85, our translation

Where the books disagree

  • Unagi: the Player's Guide p12 calls the eel Unagi; the Japanese guide's star name for it on p142 is ウツボ (moray), and スーパーマリオブラザーズ百科 p85 gives it a card under that name.